Chief Inspector Boyle: “Anti-White” sentiment among minority officers

Chief Inspector Anthony Boyle said this regarding members of the Philadelphia Police Department.  There is “an anti-white sentiment among some of the minority officers.”

Is this the reason he assaulted Captain Laverne Vann?    This was a national story. 

In the Divided States Of America, opinions like this are best left unsaid.  Much less by a Chief Inspector in the Philadelphia Police Department.   The statement made by Boyle, without proof, is against the stated belief system of the Philadelphia Police Department.

There is currently an environment where people feel comfortable with saying such things.  But an opinion such as this, is best kept to yourself.

Apparently, their “anti-white” sentiment didn’t prevent them from remaining silent on violating the rights of overwhelmingly black defendants, until they themselves were targeted.  Maybe they were “anti-woman beater” as Boyle allegedly physically attacked Captain Laverne Vann.

Maybe, they simply became “anti-corruption” and had enough of following illegal orders from Evers.   Some would argue they were deafening silent too long.  This could be attributed to their desire to remain in their assignments.  The public be damned.

Boyle also stated it is “It is 100 percent about attempts to get nonproductive members of the bureau to become productive or to get rid of them.”  Which most leaders can understand.  It is allegedly this reason, why Boyle clashed with Staff Inspector Debra Frazier.

It is alleged Boyle simply wanted Frazier to actually arrive at work, which rumor has it, that Frazier rarely did.

The story in today’s Inquirer will certainly bolster the lawsuit against Boyle and Evers.  Maybe this is why Frazier is leaving 2 years of DROP on the table to exit early.  In the lawsuit against Evers and Boyle, Frazier and the other plaintiffs, also allege racism.

There have been many allegations about hostility and racism in the Narcotics Bureau for quite some time.

Congressman Steve King (R-Iowa) actually said to a New York Times reporter in a piece that was released last week that “White nationalist, white supremacist, Western civilization — how did that language become offensive?” He later added, “Why did I sit in classes teaching me about the merits of our history and our civilization?”

We all know the lessons from history about believing one group is superior to another group.  We all know the lessons from history and what happened in Europe with the “Nationalist” movement by one Adolf Hitler.

Keep your divisive opinion to yourself.  Especially if you allegedly giving orders that are violating the civil rights of mostly minorities.

Chief Inspector Anthony Boyle and Inspector Ray Evers must be made to answer for their dereliction of duty and this case must be reviewed for possible criminal charges.  Dollars to donuts that when their social media accounts are subpoenaed for the civil case, it will be very telling.

Don’t try scrubbing your social media now fellas, it doesn’t work.

Captain Laverne Vann alleged in a lawsuit filed against the City and Boyle and Evers that members of her unit were ordered to falsify property  and chain of custody records on drugs, money and other evidence if arrestees’ on drug charges were willing to flip and testify against others.

While Vann has asserted that she “secretly” asked a 25th District Sergeant, Wali Shabazz, who has his own credibility problems and is currently under investigation for theft, to quickly charge a defendant after being told not to by EversVann also failed in her duty to report this incident immediately.

Evers also has a colorful history which includes drunken fights, trying to abuse his authority down the shore and an allegation of rape of a Temple student.  Philadelphia Magazine warned the Police Department that Evers may be unsuitable for a high-profile job.

Evers “initiative” isn’t the first illegal conduct to go down in the annals of the police department.  Does anyone remember then Captain Thomas Nestel started an “initiative” of taking anyone in the 25th District who didn’t have identification on them?  The Police Counsel’s office stopped that illegal practice after it was reported by a police supervisor.

Vann should have said “NO”!  It was an illegal order.  Vann should have went to the FBI, if she was fearful.  Vanns’ response also fell short.

Unfortunately, Officer Nathaniel Harper will probably catch the most heat.  At least he verbalized that he felt he had to “follow orders”.  Even orders that he felt were illegal and wrong.  Does the Nuremberg trials come to mind for anyone?

It should be noted that retaliation is a real fear in the Police Department.  However; this is where your personal integrity and moral compass takes over.  Just Say NO!!!

Boyle and Evers are in deep doggy doo.   But so is everyone who engaged in this pattern and practice of illegal and immoral conduct.

There will probably be alot of cases thrown out because of their malfeasance.  The Internal Affairs report concluded that “This investigation SUSTAINED that Chief Inspector Anthony Boyle” “failed to supervise.”

The report also concluded “This investigations SUSTAINED that Inspector Raymond Evers”, “abused his authority and SUSTAINED that he failed to supervise his subordinates.”

“Additionally it is SUSTAINED that Inspector Raymond Evers” “lied during this investigation.”

The ball is now in the court of Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner.  The report also stated the District Attorney’s Office had not been notified about the cases the actions of these officers.

Now Krasner is aware.  Knowledge is Power.

evers

Shots Fired: DA Krasner Cleans House!

Newly sworn-in Philadelphia District Attorney, Larry Krasner, has started the new year with a BANG!  Dozens of Assistant District Attorney’s were sent packing with dozens of others shaking in their boots!

Krasner, who took over the 534 employee department on January 2, provided no official comment on the terminations.  See the partial leaked list below:

E. Marc Costanzo

Pat Blessington

Trial Division Chief John Delaney, Jr.

Pre-Trial Unit Chief Michael Barry

Chief of the Diversion Courts Unit Derek Riker

Chief of Family Violence & Sexual Assault James Carpenter

Gun Violence Task Force Chief Carolien Keating-McGlynn

DA Conviction Review Unit Marc Gilson

Chief of the Legislation & Policy Unit Greg Rowe

Lauren Realberg

Jason Kleinbahn

Laquan Lightfoot

Melissa Francis DAO’s Danger Drug Offenders Unit

Brian Hughes

Andrew Notaristefano

Tom Lipscomb

Bridget Kirn

Joe Whitehead

Laurie Moore

Namratha Ravikant

Gwen Cujdik

Brian Zarallo

Yvonne Ruiz

Michelle Seidner

Jan McDermott

Salina Jones

Hugh Burns

B.J. Graham-Rubin

Stacey Hughes

Carlos Vega

Nicole Pedecino

Jenn Hoffman

We all remember Costanzo and Blessington from the Porngate scandal.  The “pitbull” Marc Gilson states he was “shocked”.  Many of the others allegedly had dubious convictions and/or misconduct allegations.

nwtmdgilsonx1200-1-768x432Mark Gilson – Bye-Bye

According to triblive.com, “Some of those let go, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss their termination, said they were told Friday morning to come to the office as soon as possible. When they arrived, they said, they were escorted by the office’s detectives as they learned their fate – often without explanation – and cleaned out their desks. Several left in tears.

Andrew Notaristefano, a homicide prosecutor and district attorney’s office employee for more than a decade, said he had a homicide trial scheduled to start Monday – and that he’d met with the victim’s family Thursday night to prepare. He was at his desk working Friday when a human resources employee took him aside and told him he was fired, he said.

Notaristefano, who secured dozens of murder convictions during his career, said he was given “no explanation.” He requested to leave after prosecuting his upcoming trial but was told no, he said. His request to speak to Krasner was also denied, he said.

“I’ve worked very hard and sacrificed a lot to make this city a safer place and to help people,” said Notaristefano, part of the team of prosecutors that unsuccessfully sought the death penalty last fall in a retrial for a decades-old murder.

Michael Barry, deputy of the pretrial division, confirmed that he was asked to resign, with his last day next Friday. James Carpenter, chief of the Family Violence and Sexual Assault Unit for the past six years, said he would also leave that day.

Derek Riker, chief of the Diversion Courts Unit for the last five years, said he was shocked to be let go because “I consider myself one of the progressive people in the office,” responsible for cases that involve alternative treatment and programs instead of incarceration – the types of ideals Krasner campaigned to expand.

Gwenn Cujdik, a homicide prosecutor, asked what would happen if she didn’t resign as requested. She said she was told she would be fired on Monday.

“A lot of us stayed because we were willing to stay and willing to work for (Krasner) and continue to do what we do,” Cujdik said.”

Uh……Yeah.  It is not unusual for the incoming District Attorney to make staffing changes.  Ed Rendell, former District Attorney, Mayor and Governor states he dismissed about 25 percent of staff when he first took office.

 

Philly DA Detective Retaliated Against for Cooperating with Feds, Lawyer Claims

In the Philadelphia Police Department, when you “snitch” on your own, you will be singled out, retaliated against and fired at the smallest infraction.  In many cases, Internal Affairs will look for infractions or baseless allegations, to rid the department of those who violate the “stop snitching” culture within the Police Department.

It seems now, in the District Attorney’s Office of Philadelphia, whistleblowers need protection from supervisors within the County Detectives Unit who were loyal to disgraced former District Attorney Rufus Seth Williams.  According to Detective Pierre Gomez, a former 12 year veteran Philly cop who is now a Prosecution Detective 1 in the DA’s office, claims he is now being retaliated against because of his cooperation with the Feds which resulted in the imprisonment of Seth Williams.

What, witness intimidation in the DA’s office?  The same office who charge people with witness intimidation.  Apparently, the supervisors over there didn’t get the memo.  They have misplaced loyalty to a convicted felon.

Whistleblowers are maligned, mistreated and misrepresented.  When a whistleblower reports misconduct they immediately subject themselves to retaliation.  This is as common in the law enforcement culture as well across the broad spectrum of business organizations.  It is a culture where “snitching” is taboo.

Pierre Gomez is learning his lesson the hard way.  Gomez was bodyguard for Seth Williams during his tenure as the Philly DA.  In this capacity, Gomez was with Seth during his infamous interactions about that red 1997 Jaguar XK8 that the owner of Woody’s bar gave Williams which was a subject of the subsequent FBI investigation.

Gomez was there during the infamous meeting at the Union League, in which then-Chief Inspector Joseph Sullivan, decided to showboat, after doing everything in his power to assist Seth in his misdeeds, to allow a Jordanian born businessman, Mohammed Ali, bypass extra screening by our diligent Homeland Security folks in Customs, BEFORE he was told that Seth’s days were numbered.

So you see, Gomez would have been the perfect guy for the Feds.  Gomez was given immunity and cooperated with the feds for two years.  You can see how misguided loyalty will motivate his supervisors to try to get intelligence from him when it was discovered he was cooperating.

Gomez alleges that his supervisor, Kenyatta Lee, who is a Lieutenant in the unit and also a from Philly cop, tried pumping Gomez for information.  Gomez claims he gave Lee minimal information.

Kenyatta Lee
Kenyatta Lee

 

Kenyatta Lee, who was assigned to the 24th District at the time, was disciplined for his role in the making of  t-shirts that glamorized the July 12 beating of suspect Thomas Jones.   Lee was placed on desk duty in DPR and then formally disciplined.   Both 24th District police captains were also disciplined for failing to stop the distribution of the shirts within the Philadelphia Police Department.

It was a huge black eye for the city at the time because of the RNC, which the t-shirts referenced, and the Jones beating was being compared to the Rodney King beating.

Lee was also a trustee with FOP Lodge #5 as well.  It should be noted that the time of the t-shirt caper, President of the FOP, John McNesby was a police officer with Lee in the 24th District at the time.

Lee would have reason to hate whistleblowers because it was whistleblowers who went to then-Commissioner John Timoney after none of the supervisors in the district intervened.   Internal Affairs swarmed the 24th and 25th Districts to interview cops.  Even though Internal Affairs did over 100 interviews in the districts, not one police officer claimed to know who made the tee-shirts.  And only a handful admitted to even seeing them at all, even though there were photos of cops wearing the shirts inside the district.

UPI reported at the time:
“Philadelphia – (7-21-00) Narcotics officer Kenyatta Lee has been disciplined for his role in the making of T-shirts that glamorize the July 12 beating of suspect Thomas Jones. Two police captains were also disciplined for failing to stop the distribution of the T-shirts within the Philadelphia Police Department. Officer Kenyatta Lee is to be reassigned to a desk job where he will take complaints about small crimes.
“Welcome, America” was printed on the back of the T-shirts in bright blue,
two-inch-high letters. A black-and-white picture shows a swarm of officers
surrounding and beating Jones. On front of the shirts is an image of a badge which refers to the
Philadelphia Police Department and the upcoming Republican National
Convention. Police said Officer Kenyatta Lee sold the shirts to other officers for $10.”

 

Gomez also stated he went up the chain and reported Lee’s conduct to his superior, who was then Claude Thomas, who was the Chief of County detectives at the time, amazingly, put in writing, that Gomez will not respond to “third party” inquires regarding Williams in an email he sent to everyone in the office.  When asked if this included subpoenas, Thomas allegedly informed Gomez that it was inclusive to his order.

claudethomas
Claude Thomas

This is the same Claude Thomas who sued Kathleen Kane for retaliation.   Gomez is alleging his was retaliated against and is demanding $200,000.00.  

Besides for leaving the office because of Seth Williams ultimate arrest and conviction, rumor has it Thomas resigned because he was living in Delaware while assigned to the DA’s office.

Larry Krasner will certainly be made aware of these latest developments.  Krasner has a HUGE problem with this kind of conduct.